Buyers Guides » Gold Dealers » Best Gold Dealers Columbus, OH

Best Gold Dealers Columbus, OH

We chose the best gold dealers in Columbus, OH, based on their selection, costs and customer reviews.

Latest update: June 26, 2024

Gold Dealers Columbus, OH

Patriot Gold Group

With a fast turnaround for new accounts (24-hour setup) and a simple 3-step process to begin, Patriot makes Gold IRAs simple to start and affordable to manage.

Orion Metal Exchange

Orion Metals Exchange is an affordable precious metals dealer that provides direct pricing, low management costs, as well as a variety of services, including an easy-to-set-up IRA account.

Lear Capital

Lear Capital's low annual management cost, 24-hour purchase protections, and quality customer service make it a great option for individuals interested in a precious metals IRA.

American Hartford Gold

American Hartford Gold specializes in Gold and Silver IRAs and buying and selling gold and silver for physical possession. It uses a three-step process for acquiring precious metals for physical delivery, Gold IRAs or a precious metals IRA.

Premier Gold

Open a gold IRA with the help of a trained specialist or buy physical precious metals for home storage directly on the website. Premier Gold’s unique data-backed investor simulator tool can help you learn how adjusting your portfolio allocations can affect your annual returns.


The Metalsmart tool is the first company to allow consumers to source and compare offers from highly-vetted, top-rated gold dealers. Consumers can view real-time pricing estimates and choose the best company to buy from. This can help customers to save up to 15% on gold and silver prices by eliminating high dealer markups.

Gold Alliance

Gold Alliance's team is equipped with both financial and precious metals experts. Gold Alliance is known for client satisfaction.

ITrustCapital Gold IRA

iTrustCapital is an affordable self-trade investment platform used to buy and sell precious metals and cryptocurrencies. The platform uses a transparent fee structure, making it easy and accessible for all investors.

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry

Buy and sell gold, silver and platinum coins and bullion, along with jewelry. Find US and world government-minted bullion, US and world gold coins, collectible sets and more. New items come in regularly.

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn

Carries gold and silver coins and bullion, along with jewelry and other collectibles. Strives to pay you more for your precious metals. Staff has numismatic experience and can provide written appraisals.

Buy Here Sell Here

Licensed pawnbroker. Sell your unwanted or broken gold and precious metals for cash. Shop for jewelry, gold and other items at low prices on eBay or in the store.

Mr. Bills Collectibles

Get cash for gold, silver, platinum, bullion and scrap jewelry. Call to set up a free appraisal. Shop a wide selection of collectibles and memorabilia in store or online, including great deals on gold, silver coins, and jewelry.

Grove City Coin & Currency

Specializes in coin buying and selling. Belongs to the American Numismatic Association. Pays cash for many forms of gold, silver and platinum.

Gold Rush Jewelers

Buys gold, silver, watches, and diamonds, with high cash payouts. Sells watches and jewelry.

Old Hilliard Coin & Fine Art, LLC

Offers monthly and quarterly coin or bullion-based plans for a set fee so investors and collectors can steadily build a collection of high-quality items. Buys and sells precious metals coins and bullion. Shop in store by appointment or view items online.

Gold and other precious metals are an investment and carry risk. Consumers should be alert to claims that customers can make a lot of money in these or any investment with little risk. As with any investment, you can lose money and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance results. Consumers should also obtain a clear understanding of the fees associated with any investment before agreeing to invest.

Gold Dealer Costs and Fees in Columbus, OH

Investment grade precious metals range in value from silver at the lowest, platinum next, gold and then palladium. Select dealers carry rhodium, which typically has the highest price.

Gold dealers add a premium to precious metal bullion for sale, typically about 2-8% over current market value. When buying gold or other metals, take time to check the spot price, which is the same as current market value. This value is listed publicly and changes constantly. The amount over spot that a dealer is charging is the premium. When completing a precious metals transaction, a reputable dealer should have spot prices posted or should inform the customer so it’s clear what the mark-up is. Some dealers are willing to negotiate their margins, especially for bulk purchases.

Another fee associated with physical gold investment: storage. Think about where you’ll keep the gold. For small amounts, a safety deposit box at a bank could cost about $50-$175 per year. Larger quantities of physical gold might be best stored in a vault or depository; these facilities typically charge a percentage of the metal’s total worth.

For investment in a gold IRA, expect to pay set-up fees, annual maintenance fees and storage fees. Some gold accounts trade gold; be aware of trade fees and commissions.

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry is a precious metals, coin, and jewelry dealer. Customers can shop a large inventory of US and world coins and bullion, including bullion from popular private mints. You can also buy or sell gold, silver, coins, and other precious items with options for any budget. For sellers, evaluations are done with X-ray fluorescence so staff can quickly determine what your items are made of. Reviewers give this business five stars for friendly and knowledgeable assistance and reasonable prices. Customers value the great customer service from associates who take time to answer questions and are transparent about the buying and selling process.

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry
Address 190 Graceland Blvd, Columbus, OH 43214
Phone Number (614) 846-4653

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn

Gemco Coins Jewelry & Pawn has been buying and selling gold and silver coins, bullion, and jewelry since 1988. They strive to pay you more than competitors for your items. Customers can find weekly specials on their website. Items are for sale in store and on eBay. Reviewers like the selection and say that the owner is friendly, knowledgeable, patient, and fair. One customer said it was an amazing place for coin collectors of Morgan dollars.

Gemco Coins Jewelry and Pawn
Address 5311 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228
Phone Number (614) 878-2646

Buy Here Sell Here

Buy Here Sell Here

Buy Here Sell Here is a licensed pawn shop offering full pawnbroker services. You can turn your unwanted or broken gold or precious metals into cash or check out items for sale at low prices in store or on eBay. Customers like the selection of items and the staff’s willingness to negotiate on prices. Reviewers give high marks for friendly, patient, and honest ownership and employees, along with a quick and easy transaction process.

Buy Here Sell Here
Address 1257 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222
Phone Number (614) 235-6400

Mr. Bill’s Collectibles

Mr. Bill's Collectibles

Customers can earn cash for collectibles and precious metals at Mr. Bill’s Collectibles. Free appraisals can be scheduled by calling. Great deals on gold, coins and jewelry can be found in the store or online at eBay. Sell coins, medals, silver, gold, platinum, bullion, jewelry and scrap. Reviewers consistently give this business five stars.

Mr. Bill’s Collectibles
Address 4589 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213
Phone Number (614) 370-4653

Grove City Coin & Currency

Grove City Coin & Currency

Grove City Coin & Currency offers the most cash for coins, gold, silver, platinum and more. Customers can talk with a numismatic expert to evaluate coins and currency. The business buys many platinum items, including scrap, along with rare coins, unwanted and scrap gold, and many forms of silver. Customers like the owner’s knowledge of coins and say the staff took time to answer questions. Several reviewers mentioned high payout prices and the unique items for sale.

Grove City Coin & Currency
Address 2655 Columbus St, Grove City, OH 43123
Phone Number (614) 946-3846

Gold Rush Jewelers

Gold Rush Jewelers

Gold Rush Jewelers pays cash for gold, silver, jewelry, coins, bullion, scrap and more. Customers appreciate the store’s beautiful selection of jewelry. Reviewers like that this shop paid them the most for their gold and diamond jewelry and that the customer service was great.

Gold Rush Jewelers
Address 10 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081
Phone Number (614) 267-9200

Old Hilliard Coin & Fine Art, LLC

Old Hilliard Coin & Fine Art, LLC

Old Hilliard Coin & Fine Art buys and sells gold and silver bullion as well as US and foreign numismatic and precious metals coins for collectors and investors. Advice is freely given, but customers must make an appointment. This business offers a unique monthly coin club which is great for those just starting out or more experienced investors and collectors. Starting at $150 quarterly, customers can get a hand-picked selection of coins or bars delivered to regularly to keep building an investment. Reviewers like the quality of items they received by joining the coin club, the great selection in the store, and the excellent options for diversified options in the metals market.

Old Hilliard Coin & Fine Art, LLC
Address 5275 Norwich St, Hilliard, OH 43026
Phone Number (614) 334-2722

We believe everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. As a result, we provide our buyers guides and local guides free for consumers.

We may receive compensation from our partners. However, Retirement Living independently researches companies, and the compensation we receive does not affect the analysis of our staff or the opinions of our subject matter experts. The subject matter experts mentioned in our guides have specific knowledge or credentials in their field.

Retirement Living will not include companies on our guides that do not meet our quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear. As an Amazon Associate Retirement Living earns from qualifying purchases.

Retirement Living independently researches companies, and we use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on our staff's judgement or subject matter expert's judgement. We do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and we do not receive compensation for these designations.

Additionally, Retirement Living is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to,, or

couple on the beach enjoying retirement Want exclusive content and tips on retirement planning?