Buyers Guides » Gold Dealers » Best Gold Dealers Indianapolis, IN

Best Gold Dealers Indianapolis, IN

We chose the best gold dealers in Indianapolis, IN, based on their selection, costs and customer reviews.

Latest update: January 19, 2023

Gold Dealers Indianapolis, IN

Patriot Gold Group

With a fast turnaround for new accounts (24-hour setup) and a simple 3-step process to begin, Patriot makes Gold IRAs simple to start and affordable to manage.

Lear Capital

With a low annual management cost and a reputation for good customer service, Lear Capital is a great option for individuals interested in a precious metals IRA.

Orion Metal Exchange

Orion Metals Exchange is an affordable precious metals dealer that provides direct pricing, low management costs, as well as a variety of services, including an easy-to-set-up IRA account.

Monetary Gold

Monetary Gold buys precious metals directly from the source to keep prices down. The brokerage offers an expanded range of investments via registration with the world's largest derivatives marketplace. Monetary Gold provides workshops and individual consultations, so clients understand markets and investment options.

Gold Alliance

Gold Alliance's team is equipped with both financial and precious metals experts. Gold Alliance is known for client satisfaction.

Birch Gold Group

Birch Gold Group specializes in Precious Metals IRAs and strives to provide customers with the right information so they can make the appropriate decisions for their financial future. Precious metal offerings include Gold, Silver, Platinum and Palladium.

Advantage Gold

Advantage Gold Is a precious metals company that specializes in educating their customers to help them make educated investing decisions.

Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange

Buy and sell gold, silver and platinum bullion and jewelry. Deals in rare and valuable coins, with trained staff to evaluate your collection. Inventory updated regularly.

Petite G Jewelers

Trade in unwanted gold for store credit and get 20% above current value. Offers custom jewelry design and large selection of jewelry for sale. 14-day return policy.

American Jeweler

Offers current market value when buying scrap and precious metals. Appraises collections and buys out estates. Sells unique and custom jewelry, with a wide selection online including prices.

Hoosier Coin & Currency (By Appointment Only)

Shop online with a 14-day money-back return policy. Make an appointment to buy or sell gold, silver and bullion in person at the shop or to get an appraisal.

Avon Cash for Gold Indiana

Buys and sells gold, silver, platinum, jewelry and more. Watch as a staff member sorts and evaluates your items and makes a cash offer. Browse precious metals and resale jewelry in the shop.

The Coin Index

Retail and wholesale precious metals dealers. Offers a selection of precious metals, including world and US coins, most types of bullion, silver, gold, platinum and palladium.

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Full service, family-run coin ship since 1983. Buy and sell collectible coins, bullion and more. Shop a comprehensive selection online. Free appraisals, walk-ins welcome.

Sam Shafer Numismatics

Specializes in buying and selling rare coins. Belongs to AMA, PCGS, NGC and Central States Numismatic Society. Make an appointment for a free, no-obligation consultation.

Gold and other precious metals are an investment and carry risk. Consumers should be alert to claims that customers can make a lot of money in these or any investment with little risk. As with any investment, you can lose money and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance results. Consumers should also obtain a clear understanding of the fees associated with any investment before agreeing to invest.


Gold Dealer Costs and Fees in Indianapolis, IN

When buying investment grade precious metals, also called bullion, be aware of the fees associated with a transaction. Gold dealers typically add a premium to the price of any precious metal, which should range from about 2-8%. The premium is the amount the dealer charges above the spot price, or current market value, of the metal. Spot prices change throughout the day according to the market and are listed publicly so anyone can check. Dealers should have spot prices posted at the shop or easily accessible during price negotiations.

Another fee to consider when investing in physical gold is storage. Banks charge about $50 to $175 per year for a small safety deposit box. At a vault or depository, the cost for storage is typically a percentage of the worth of the metal you’re storing.

Though gold IRAs allow consumers to invest in gold without acquiring it physically, there are fees that come with these accounts. Expect to pay set up fees, annual maintenance fees, and storage fees.


Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange

Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange

Midwest Jewelry & Coin exchange is an upscale boutique dedicated to providing complete service for casual collectors and advanced investors alike. Staff is trained with comprehensive knowledge of coins. The business also buys gold, silver and platinum, along with estate jewelry, and aims to offer the best prices in town. Reviewers are happy with Midwest Jewelry & Coin’s unique coin selection, fair prices, and respectful staff. Several reviewers note that this is a great place to buy, sell or trade.

Midwest Jewelry & Coin Exchange
Address 1340 E 86th St Suite 52, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone Number (317) 844-9596


Petite G Jewelers

Petite G Jewelers

Petite G Jewelers is a full service jewelry shop. They can design a custom piece for you, you can sell unwanted gold, or you can trade in your unwanted items for store credit for the best deal and receive 20% above current value. Customers can shop online or in person. Reviewers note that staff is friendly and helpful and that the store offers a variety of price points. Many reviewers mention the pleasant atmosphere and quality service.

Petite G Jewelers
Address 5609 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Phone Number (317) 255-5555


American Jeweler

American Jeweler

American Jeweler offers current market value when buying your gold, silver, platinum and scrap gold. Ask about first responder and military discounts. Find a transparent pricing on a selection of jewelry, components, and investment grade gold for sale online. Pieces can be customized online or in store. Reviewers note that the owner was competent, thorough, well-informed and kind, and that he offered good prices and discounts. Customers report satisfaction with their purchases and the selection of items for sale.

American Jeweler
Address 3632 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Phone Number (317) 290-8218


Hoosier Coin & Currency (By Appointment Only)

Hoosier Coin & Currency (By Appointment Only)

Hoosier Coin Shop buys and sells coins, silver, gold and bullion. To give customers the best service, they work by appointment only. Customers can also shop a limited selection online, with prices listed and a 14-day money back return policy. Reviewers like the good prices when purchasing or selling, and say that the owners were friendly and informative. Customers liked the wide range of coins, which is great for beginner collectors or advanced investors.

Hoosier Coin & Currency (By Appointment Only)
Address 192 N Avon Ave #340, Avon, IN 46123
Phone Number (317) 268-6159


Avon Cash for Gold Indiana

Avon Cash for Gold Indiana

Avon Cash for Gold buys and sells gold, silver, platinum, bullion and more. Customers can walk in for a quote and walk out with cash in hand. Bring any item you think contains precious metal for a free no-obligation evaluation based on weight, type of metal, and daily market value. Reviewers say this shop is a great place for buying and selling, and that staff was professional and friendly. Customers experienced fair pricing and great service. One reviewer was especially happy with the price he got for bullion coins.

Avon Cash for Gold Indiana
Address 7485 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN 46123
Phone Number (317) 268-4963


The Coin Index

The Coin Index

TThe Coin Index sells a wide selection of investment grade gold, silver, platinum, palladium, coins and more. Customers can shop on eBay or visit the store. The business is a member of ANA, PCGS and NGC. They accept credit and debit cards and are open on Saturdays. Reviewers like the friendly, easy to work with staff and the prices that were better than competitors. One customer mentioned that the shop can order something special for you if they don’t have it.

The Coin Index
Address 857 N Madison Ave, Greenwood, IN 46142
Phone Number (317) 885-8065


Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

You can buy or sell any numismatic coins and any gold, silver or platinum bullion with Lost Dutchman Rare Coins. Shop online for a wide variety of precious metals products, including bars from world mints, colonial and territorial coins, and pre-1933 gold coins. This business also offers free in-office appraisals and numismatic consulting and accepts PCGS, PMG, NGC and CAC submissions. Reviewers said they found great deals, a great selection, and rare items, including ancient coins. Customers liked the polite and helpful staff and appreciated the numismatic expertise.

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins
Address 4983 N Franklin Rd, Lawrence, IN 46226
Phone Number (317) 545-7650


Sam Shafer Numismatics

Sam Shafer Numismatics

Sam Shafer Numismatics specializes in buying and selling rare coins. Collectors and sellers with all levels of experience are welcome. The shop’s wide-ranging inventory includes unique items and coins in most price ranges. The business also offers a free 30-minute consultation with your coin collection. Reviewers consistently give this business five stars. Customers encountered knowledgeable staff, great service, great deals, and fair prices. Several reviewers especially appreciated the private appointment and the respectful staff.

Sam Shafer Numismatics
Address 2nd Floor 11 Municipal Dr Suite 200, Fishers, IN 46038
Phone Number (317) 721-3573

We believe everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. As a result, we provide our buyers guides and local guides free for consumers.

We may receive compensation from our partners. However, Retirement Living independently researches companies, and the compensation we receive does not affect the analysis of our staff or the opinions of our subject matter experts. The subject matter experts mentioned in our guides have specific knowledge or credentials in their field.

Retirement Living will not include companies on our guides that do not meet our quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear. As an Amazon Associate Retirement Living earns from qualifying purchases.

Retirement Living independently researches companies, and we use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on our staff's judgement or subject matter expert's judgement. We do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and we do not receive compensation for these designations.

Additionally, Retirement Living is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, amazon.ca, or amazon.co.uk.

couple on the beach enjoying retirement Want exclusive content and tips on retirement planning?