Best Medicare Supplement Companies in Illinois

Updated:

We chose the best Medicare supplement companies in Illinois based on coverage options, costs, and customer reviews.

Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More

Lubbock, TX
Humana logo
4.5 Stars

Humana

Humana offers Medicare Supplement Plans A through N in most states. Each Humana policy comes with benefits other companies don’t offer. Perks include discounts for using electronic payments, fitness programs and more.

Cigna logo
4.4 Stars

Cigna

Cigna is an industry-leading Medicare Supplement insurance whose plans work with any provider that takes Medicare. Cigna offers plans for Part A through N.

Mutual of Omaha logo
4.3 Stars

Mutual of Omaha

Mutual of Omaha is a leading Medigap provider whose members file fewer complaints than competitors. The company offers an impressive array of Medicare-related articles on its website explaining how to navigate the enrollment period, eligibility rules and how to use Medigap insurance.

Blue Cross Blue Shield logo
4.5 Stars

Blue Cross Blue Shield

Blue Cross Blue Shield provides Medicare supplement insurance and personalized, affordable health plans. The company serves nearly one out of every three consumers who buy health insurance. Around 95% of health care providers contract with Blue Cross Blue Shield companies.

Aetna Medicare Supplement logo
3.8 Stars

Aetna Medicare Supplement

Aetna offers Medicare Supplement insurance plans offering coverage that works with Original Medicare (Parts A and B). Aetna’s website provides helpful information on plans in each state and convenient online policy management.

CoverRight logo
4.5 Stars

CoverRight

CoverRight provides everything you need to select insurance that covers the gaps in Original Medicare coverage. You can find everything you need online, and a licensed advisor is available by phone, email, or chat to help. CoverRight offers quotes from over 20 insurance companies, and all services are free.

Illinois Health Agents

They guarantee all Medicare supplement plans, with no health questions asked. Enrollees can choose their doctors or specialists, with the option to save on premiums using the Medicare Select options and in-network providers.

Senior Services of Illinois

Authorized exclusive provider for Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois. Guaranteed acceptance for all applicants. The most popular plans pay Medicare Part A hospital deductibles and copays, skilled nursing copays, and cover foreign travel emergency care.

Integrity Insurance and Financial Services

Offers Medicare supplement plans from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois, including Medicare Select Network plans with lower premiums when you agree to use providers within the network. Work with a professional agent to select the right plan for you.

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois

Provides Medicare supplement coverage with guaranteed acceptance. Premium discounts are available for select members. New Plan G Plus offers a 24/7 nurse line, hearing exam, vision and dental benefits and fitness perks.

The Insurance Office

Local Medicare specialist that offers a free consultation to learn about your options and enroll in a plan that fits your needs. Member of National Association of Senior Advocates and American Association for Medicare Supplement Insurance.

Wes Drew – Insurance Agent

Independent agent specializing in insurance needs for seniors. Learn about your coverage options for Medicare supplemental plans and get help enrolling in the plan that’s right for you.

Health Alliance

Offers four Medicare supplement plans: A, G, High deductible G and N. Benefits include skilled nursing coverage, $0 copay for hospitalization, and Medicare deductibles. Select plans have no deductible.

Boettcher Insurance Agency

Independent local insurance broker representing various carriers. Specializes in Medicare and supplemental policies. Helps clients in St. Charles, Naperville and Chicagoland find the right coverage for their needs and budget.

HealthMarkets Insurance – Andrew Choi

Provides no-cost assistance in shopping for and enrolling in insurance plans, including Medicare supplement coverage. Represents a variety of national carriers to offer supplement plans A, B, D, G, K, L, M and N.

 

Medicare Supplement Costs in Illinois


The State of Illinois Department on Aging Senior Health Insurance Program provides a comparison guide to help seniors shop for Medicare supplement plans. For a male 65-year-old non-smoker, plan A annual premiums range from $1,100 to $2,300. In Illinois, plan G might be a good choice because it covers all Medicare Supplement benefits except Part B deductible costs, with a reasonable monthly premium.

Illinois Medicare Supplement Costs by Plan (Annual Premiums)
Plan Monthly Premiums (Range)
Plan A $85 – $411
Plan B $121 – $407
Plan D $119 – $396
Plan G $98 – $509
Plan G High $32 – $90
Plan K $56 – $175
Plan L $70 – $274
Plan M $96 – $265
Plan N $76 – $483

For a 65-year-old person. Data collected on Medicare.gov. Prices are accurate as of publication.

When budgeting for your coverage, be sure to consider can monthly premiums and yearly deductibles. Illinois residents under 65 who enroll in Medicare supplemental plans will pay higher premiums overall. Premiums will vary depending on your insurer and how your premium is rated.

When Should You Enroll in an Illinois Medicare Supplement Plan?

New in 2022, if an Illinois resident is between age 65 and 75, and has an existing Medicare supplement policy, the individual is entitled to a new annual open enrollment period. The individual can sign up for a new Medigap policy (from the same provider) without medical underwriting. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois offers Medicare supplement guaranteed issue rights at any time. You might get guaranteed issue rights in other citations, such as moving outside the coverage area or your plan coverage ends through no fault of your own. Illinois also allows you to change from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare within the first year of your enrollment. Browse the state’s complete list of special enrollment periods to determine what applies to you. In Illinois, the Medicare initial enrollment period is three months before and after your 65th birthday. Individuals with disabilities or End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) can also enroll, even if they’re under 65. Open enrollment in a Medicare supplement plan, or Medigap, lasts six months from when your Medicare Part B becomes active. During this one-time election period, enrollees have guaranteed issue rights, which means insurers cannot turn down applicants or charge more based on medical history. After this six-month window, Illinois residents can still sign up for Medicare supplement plans, but Medigap applicants will be subject to medical underwriting and can be denied or charged higher premiums based on medical history.

Medicare Enrollment in Illinois

Illinois partners with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid to contract health plans and coordinate delivery of services for participating enrollees. Illinois residents who sign up for Medicare supplement plans have a 30-day “free look” period to review the policy, cancel the plan, and receive a full refund if they choose. All standardized Medicare supplement plans are renewable for life.

Illinois Medicare Supplement Company Reviews

Illinois Health Agents

Illinois Health Agents partners with Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois (BCBSIL) to provide Medicare supplement plans. Reviewers praise this company for helping them navigate the enrollment process and compare options with friendly and professional service. They also offer Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement Plans, which usually have the lowest rates using the attained-age rating approach to plan pricing.

Discount Program offers discounts on vision services, fitness clubs, weight management, complementary alternative medicine, hearing care and more.

Accepts all applicants for Medigap policies, no health questions asked

Address 3501 N Southport Ave #207, Chicago, IL 60657
Phone Number (312) 726-6565
Illinois Health Agents

Senior Services of Illinois

Senior Services of Illinois is an independent, authorized exclusive agent for Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois, offering both Medicare Advantage and Medicare supplement plans. The company scores five stars for thorough and knowledgeable patient agents who can help clients select the best plan for their needs. They also list plan prices each year on their website.

Guaranteed to match Medicare’s cost increases

Guaranteed acceptance to Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare supplement plans, and are free to choose any doctors or specialists

Address 18330 Distinctive Dr, Orland Park, IL 60467
Phone Number 1 (866) 451-1979
Senior Services of Illinois

Integrity Insurance and Financial Services

Integrity Insurance and Financial Services offers a full range of insurance services, including Medicare supplement plans from Blue Cross. Customers across the board appreciate the knowledgeable and helpful agents who follow up each year to ensure enrollees remain satisfied with their plans.

Additional protections such as skilled nursing facility care coinsurance and foreign travel emergency care

Experienced, professional agents

Address 18330 Distinctive Dr, Orland Park, IL 60467
Phone Number 1 (866) 451-1979
Integrity Insurance and Financial Services

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois offers a variety of Medicare supplement insurance plans with no medical underwriting. The company also provides lower-cost options with Medicare Select, but applicants for those plans will be subject to a health screening and must use in-network providers to avoid higher costs. Customer reviews suggest challenges regarding customer service, but many praise the friendly and knowledgeable representatives.

Additional protections such as skilled nursing facility care coinsurance and foreign travel emergency care

Medicare Select options

Address 300 E Randolph St, Chicago, IL 60601
Phone Number (312) 653-6000
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois

The Insurance Office

The Insurance Office specializes in helping with Medicare and Medicare supplement enrollment. A local Medicare specialist will help you compare coverage from multiple providers to find the best plan for your needs and budget. Clients consistently gave this business five stars for thorough help navigating Medicare options and finding coverage at a fair price.

Outstanding service and empathic agents

Free consultations

Address 3907 North North Street, Peoria, IL 61614
Phone Number (309) 267-0439
The Insurance Office

Wes Drew – Insurance Agent

Wes Drew Insurance Agent is an independent insurance broker focused on the needs of seniors and retirees on Medicare or approaching eligibility. He takes a client-focused approach to help you understand Medicare supplement coverage options. Clients give Drew five-star ratings for being patient and thorough in his explanations and providing assistance and support throughout the Medicare enrollment process. Reviewers said Wes Drew was a big help in guiding them through choosing a Medicare supplemental plan, and many recommended his services.

Meet in person, by phone or by video conference

Fast service

Address 1020 Willow Lake Dr, Metamora, IL 61548
Phone Number (309) 696-7933
Wes Drew – Insurance Agent

Health Alliance

Health Alliance offers Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare supplement coverage. The High G plan, for example, covers excess charges, skilled nursing, hospice and more with a $0 copay after deductibles are met. Call to speak with a licensed agent about which plan is best for you and get a personalized quote. While many reviewers reported challenges with coverage and customer service, others said approvals were fast and the staff resolved issues quickly.

Choose from four supplemental plans: G, N, A and G high deductible

Enter a zipcode to compare costs on the website easily

Address 3310 Fields S Dr, Champaign, IL 61822
Phone Number 1 (800) 851-3379
Health Alliance

Boettcher Insurance Agency

Boettcher Insurance Agency is an independent broker specializing in Medicare supplement policies to maximize coverage for any budget. Submit a few details on the site to obtain a secure quote. This company earned a five-star rating for making Medicare and supplemental policies easy for clients to understand. Customers said the team was polite, attentive, and personalized in their support methods.

Coverage options from multiple providers

Based in Geneva and serves St. Charles, Naperville and Chicagoland

Address 115 Campbell St Suite 104, Geneva, IL 60134
Phone Number (630) 885-8082
Boettcher Insurance Agency

HealthMarkets Insurance – Andrew Choi

Though Andrew Choi of HealthMarkets Insurance is an insurance agent, he is experienced in Medicare options for families and individuals. He works with multiple nationally recognized insurance providers to research coverage options and present clients with various options. Reviewers consistently praised Mr. Choi for his experience, knowledge of multiple carriers, attentiveness, and professionalism. Clients liked that he listened to their needs and made the process easy.

Several coverage options

Offers assistance at no cost

Address Des Plaines, IL 60018
Phone Number (847) 344-1150
HealthMarkets Insurance – Andrew Choi

Helpful Resources

Advertising Disclosure

We may earn money from our partners when you click a link, complete a form or call a phone number.

We believe everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. As a result, we provide our buyers guides and local guides free for consumers. We may receive compensation from our partners. However, Retirement Living independently researches companies, and the compensation we receive does not affect the analysis of our staff. Retirement Living will not include companies on our guides that do not meet our quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear. As an Amazon Associate Retirement Living earns from qualifying purchases.

Retirement Living independently researches companies, and we use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Great Value) based on our staff’s judgment. We do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and we do not receive compensation for these designations.

Get Insider Access

Get special offers, advice and tips from Retirement Living delivered to your inbox.

Get Insider Access

Get special offers, advice and tips from Retirement Living delivered to your inbox.