Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More
Medicare marketing warning urges retirees to watch for misleading sales pitches
Seniors should protect personal information and take time to review coverage before enrolling

Updated:
key insights:
- A senior advocacy group is warning Medicare beneficiaries about misleading sales tactics during annual enrollment, which runs through December 7.
- Warning signs include pressure to enroll, requests for sensitive information before choosing a plan, and claims that a salesperson represents Medicare.
- Retirees should review coverage changes, request written plan information, and seek independent help before switching.
Retirees comparing Medicare coverage are being urged to watch for misleading marketing that could turn an important healthcare decision into a costly mistake.
The New York Statewide Senior Action Council named misleading Medicare marketing its “Fraud of the Month” for November, highlighting sales tactics beneficiaries may encounter during annual enrollment. The organization administers New York’s Senior Medicare Patrol program.
“There are rules to protect you,” said Maria Alvarez, the council’s executive director.
The council advises caution when someone requests Medicare, Social Security, or banking information before a beneficiary has decided to enroll. It also flags claims that a private plan represents or is endorsed by Medicare or another government agency.
What the rules say
Medicare’s own marketing rules prohibit representatives from requesting bank account or credit card numbers simply to provide a quote. They also prohibit misleading use of Medicare’s name, logo, or card in promotional materials.
Contact methods matter, too. According to Medicare.gov, plan representatives generally cannot call or text prospective customers without permission unless they are already plan members. Representatives cannot arrive uninvited at someone’s home to sell coverage.
Pressure to sign immediately is another warning sign. Agents cannot demand that beneficiaries complete enrollment forms before they are ready or charge an enrollment fee.
What to do
Before meeting with a representative, the council recommends reviewing the Scope of Appointment form, which identifies the products to be discussed. Beneficiaries should also read their current plan’s Annual Notice of Change and request written information explaining how a proposed switch would affect existing coverage.
An agent’s selection may not include every available option. Medicare says representatives must disclose how many organizations they represent and how many plans they offer locally before discussing specific benefits. They must also direct beneficiaries to Medicare for information about all their options.
Beneficiaries who believe they were misled can call 1-800-MEDICARE or 1-800-633-4227. New York residents can also contact StateWide at 800-333-4374 for free, confidential, unbiased counseling.