Buyers Guides » Medicare Supplemental Insurance » Best Medicare Supplement Companies in Ohio

Best Medicare Supplement Companies in Ohio

We chose the best Medicare supplement companies in Ohio based on coverage options, costs, and customer reviews.

Latest update: October 28, 2022

Medicare Supplement Companies in Ohio

United Medicare Advisors

United Medicare Advisors simplifies finding the right Medicare supplement insurance by providing tools to compare plan benefits and costs. The company provides options from more than 20 providers to consumers across 45 states.


Humana offers Medicare supplement insurance Plans A through N in most states. Each Humana policy comes with benefits other companies don’t offer. Perks include discounts for using electronic payments, fitness programs and more.

Cigna Medicare Supplement

Cigna is an industry-leading Medicare supplement insurance company, serving 95 million customers. Plans work with any provider that takes Medicare. Cigna offers plans for Part A, B, C, D, F, HD-F, G and Part N.

Answers for Tomorrow

Independent broker with free one-on-one consultations. Helps seniors find the best Medicare solutions for their needs. Receive care nationwide with Medicare and a supplement plan. Call to discuss options.

Medicare Resource Center - Columbus

Meet with a local licensed Medicare specialist to compare and enroll in Medicare plans. No appointment is needed, and walk-ins are accepted. Works with top insurance carriers to bring multiple options to clients. Services are free.

Hyers & Associates Insurance

Independent insurance agency representing a variety of carriers and specializing in Medicare supplement plans. Agents help you compare quotes and benefits coverage from each company to choose the best plan for you. Services are free.

Ohio Health Benefits

Specializes in helping clients select Medicare supplement, Advantage and prescription drug coverage. Award-winning independent agency offering plans from various insurers. Advocates for Medicare beneficiaries, answers questions about coverage, and reviews your current situation.

Medical Mutual

Insurance provider offering Medicare Advantage, supplement and prescription drug coverage. MedMutual Supplement plans come with SilverSneakers fitness program and optional hearing, vision and dental benefits.

HealthMarkets Insurance - Don Larson

Insurance broker specializing in finding the best Medicare plans for your needs and budget. Works with multiple carriers to bring clients a range of options. Plans A. B, D, G, K, L, M and N are available. Average premiums in 2021 are $150 to $200 per month.

Medicare Supplement Costs in Ohio

Generally, the lowest monthly premium Medicare supplement plans are those with high deductibles. In Ohio, plans F and G have high deductible options you must pay before the plan begins to pay. When budgeting for your coverage, be sure to consider can monthly premiums and yearly deductibles. Premiums will vary depending on your insurer and how your premium is rated.

Ohio Medicare Supplement Costs by Plan (Annual Premiums)
Plan Monthly Premiums (Range)
Plan A $80 – $408
Plan B $121 – $379
Plan D $114 – $399
Plan G $109 – $482
Plan G High $33 – $81
Plan K $33 – $81
Plan L $71 – $278
Plan M $85 – $297
Plan N $83 – $446
For 65-year-old person. Data collected on Prices are accurate as of publication.

When Should You Enroll in an Ohio Medicare Supplement Plan?

The optimum window for enrollment in a Medicare supplement is within six months of enrolling in Medicare, three months before or after your 65th birthday. As with other states, Ohio residents have guaranteed issue rights during this timespan—meaning you can’t be denied, and you can’t be charged more for a plan based on your medical conditions. You can still apply after six months, but an insurance company can deny coverage or charge higher premiums based on your medical history. Guaranteed issue rights apply in certain other situations, such as if your Medicare supplement provider stops offering the plan or if you move out of the service area and need to select a new plan.

Medicare Enrollment In Ohio

For Ohio Medicare coverage, enrollment begins at age 65. But eligibility is also granted for younger people if they have been receiving disability benefits for 24 months or have kidney failure or ALS. In special circumstances, your right to a policy holds for 63 days after the loss of coverage.

Ohio Medicare Supplement Company Reviews

Answers for Tomorrow

Answers for Tomorrow

Answers for Tomorrow helps seniors compare plans and sign up for Medicare supplement and Advantage plans, along with prescription drug coverage. As an independent broker, the business represents multiple carriers and helps clients find the best solutions to fit their needs. Reviewers gave this business five stars for the highest quality customer service and for taking the stress out of applying for Medicare. Clients said agents genuinely cared about them, and were always available to answer questions.

Answers for Tomorrow
Address 2580 Elder Rd NE, Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone Number (614) 900-9475

Medicare Resource Center – Columbus

Medicare Resource Center - Columbus

Medicare Resource Center is a free service that helps seniors navigate Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medigap and Part D. Columbus-based Medicare specialists will walk you through the options and compare the top insurance carriers. Reviewers appreciate the company’s kind and understanding agents who offered the right information they needed to make an informed decision.

Medicare Resource Center – Columbus
Address 5212 N High St Ste. B, Columbus, OH 43214
Phone Number (614) 802-7302

Hyers & Associates Insurance

Hyers & Associates Insurance

Hyers & Associates is an independent broker providing a full range of insurance coverage, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage, and Part D. Meet or talk with a specialist to compare options and quotes from multiple insurance carriers, including Aetna, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Cigna, Humana, United Healthcare (AARP) and more. Reviewers said agents were extremely helpful with up-to-date Medicare options and were responsive to their questions.

Hyers & Associates Insurance
Address 240 Collins Ave #2, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone Number 1 (888) 901-5650

Ohio Health Benefits

Ohio Health Benefits

Ohio Health Benefits specializes in helping clients with Medicare and Medigap plans. The company is an independent broker offering coverage from multiple providers. Services are free and are available in person or by telephone and email. The award-winning business has earned high rankings for customer service, experience, and insurance knowledge.

Ohio Health Benefits
Address 125 West Ave #101, Tallmadge, OH 44278
Phone Number (330) 633-7713

Medical Mutual

Medical Mutual

Medical Mutual is an insurance provider offering both Medicare Advantage and Medicare supplement (Medigap) plans. Medical Mutual’s supplement plans include free fitness program membership, with options to add dental, vision and hearing benefits to a MedMutual supplement plan.Though many reviewers encountered mistakes and coverage denials, others said the benefits were comprehensive, and customer service was helpful.

Medical Mutual
Address 2060 E 9th St, Cleveland, OH 44115
Phone Number 1 (800) 382-5729

HealthMarkets Insurance – Don Larson

HealthMarkets Insurance - Don Larson

Don Larson is an insurance broker with Health Markets, helping clients find the Medicare plan and supplemental coverage that best meets their needs and budget. The average monthly premium for Medicare supplement plans ranges from $150 to $200. Call or email for a consultation. Don Larson earned a five-star rating for his knowledge of the complexities of health insurance, his passion for finding the best insurance products for clients and his ability to personalize plans to meet clients’ needs.

HealthMarkets Insurance – Don Larson
Address Delaware, OH 43015
Phone Number (614) 348-6634

We believe everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. As a result, we provide our buyers guides and local guides free for consumers.

We may receive compensation from our partners. However, Retirement Living independently researches companies, and the compensation we receive does not affect the analysis of our staff or the opinions of our subject matter experts. The subject matter experts mentioned in our guides have specific knowledge or credentials in their field.

Retirement Living will not include companies on our guides that do not meet our quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear. As an Amazon Associate Retirement Living earns from qualifying purchases.

Retirement Living independently researches companies, and we use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on our staff's judgement or subject matter expert's judgement. We do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and we do not receive compensation for these designations.

Additionally, Retirement Living is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to,, or

couple on the beach enjoying retirement Want exclusive content and tips on retirement planning?